The Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) has announced a controversial plan to regulate Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) by requiring service providers to obtain a licence. Critics argue that this move could curb digital freedoms and violate privacy rights in a country where access to information and free expression are already under strain.
Read More: PTA Issued 177 Telecom Licenses in FY 2023-24, Boosting Digital Connectivity
Under the proposed framework, companies must obtain a “Class Licence for Data Services” to legally offer VPN services in Pakistan. Any VPNs not provided by licensed companies will be declared illegal and blocked. The PTA claims this measure is necessary to monitor VPN traffic and address security concerns, but the plan has raised significant apprehension among digital rights activists and IT professionals.
Surveillance and Control: The licensing regime would allow the PTA to enforce extensive oversight of VPN traffic, including provisions for “Lawful Interception” equipment that service providers must supply to security agencies at their own expense. These measures would erode the anonymity VPNs are designed to offer, effectively turning them into tools for government surveillance.
Documents on the PTA’s website reveal that these licences would subject VPN providers to the same regulations as telecom companies. This includes providing authorities with access to user data, calls, and messages. Such intrusive measures have already sparked backlash when implemented for telecom services, and extending them to VPNs has intensified concerns over state surveillance.
“The government’s increasing grip on digital communications under the guise of national security is alarming,” said a digital rights expert. “VPNs are critical for ensuring privacy, especially for journalists, activists, and freelancers who rely on secure internet connections.”
Impact on Freelancers and IT Sector: The plan to “localize” VPN services has been pitched as a way to support Pakistan’s IT sector, including 2.5 million freelancers. However, critics argue that these measures could backfire by discouraging international clients and companies from working with local VPN providers due to privacy and reliability concerns.
“Why would any international entity, like a foreign bank or tech company, trust local VPNs that are subject to government monitoring?” asked Shahzad Arshad, Chairman of the Wireless & Internet Service Providers Association of Pakistan. “This policy could further isolate Pakistan from the global digital economy.”
The Pakistan Software Houses Association (P@SHA) had earlier proposed a localized VPN model to support freelancers and small IT exporters. While the PTA’s licensing regime incorporates elements of this suggestion, P@SHA Chairman Sajjad Syed emphasized that implementation should prioritize user privacy and international best practices. “A restrictive regime could harm the very freelancers it aims to help,” he cautioned.
Accessibility and Costs: The cost of obtaining a VPN licence—Rs300,000 for nationwide services and Rs100,000 for provincial services—is another contentious issue. Critics say these fees will discourage startups and small businesses from entering the market, limiting competition and innovation. Moreover, the added cost could trickle down to users, making secure internet access unaffordable for many.
Democratic Concerns: In a democratic society, the right to access information and communicate privately is fundamental. Activists warn that the PTA’s plan could further restrict digital freedoms in Pakistan, where online spaces are already heavily monitored.
“This isn’t just about VPNs; it’s about the broader trend of the state encroaching on citizens’ digital rights,” said a representative of a digital advocacy group. “Rather than fostering a free and open internet, the government is creating barriers and fostering mistrust.”
Technical Feasibility Questioned: Technical experts have also criticized the plan as impractical, arguing that blocking unlicensed VPNs is unlikely to be effective. “People will always find alternative proxies or other means to bypass restrictions,” said an IT professional. “This approach won’t stop VPN usage; it will only push it underground.”
Conclusion: The PTA’s licensing regime for VPNs has sparked significant debate, with critics warning it could undermine privacy, stifle innovation, and isolate Pakistan from the global digital community. As the government pushes forward with its plan, many are calling for a transparent and inclusive dialogue to ensure that policies protect the rights and interests of citizens in a democratic society.
