A significant tax evasion scandal has emerged within Pakistan’s banking sector, with allegations that several banks have manipulated their Advance to Deposit Ratios (ADR) to circumvent higher tax liabilities.
Read More: Veon Group Invests $15M in Mobilink Bank for Growth & Tech Advancement
Understanding ADR and Tax Implications: In Pakistan, a bank’s ADR—the ratio of its loans (advances) to customer deposits—directly influences its tax obligations. To encourage lending to the private sector, the government implemented a tiered tax system:
- ADR up to 40%: Income from investments in federal government securities taxed at 55%.
- ADR between 40% and 50%**: Tax rate set at **49%.
- ADR above 50%: Standard tax rate of 39% applies.
This structure aims to incentivize banks to increase lending, thereby stimulating economic growth.
Allegations of Manipulation: Reports indicate that certain banks have been artificially adjusting their ADRs to fall above the 50% threshold, thereby qualifying for the lower tax rate of 39%. Such manipulations are typically executed in the fourth quarter of the fiscal year to influence the ADR as of September 30, the date used for tax assessments. This practice not only undermines the government’s fiscal policies but also constitutes a significant loss of revenue.
Legal Challenges and Government Response: In response to these tax provisions, several banks sought legal recourse, obtaining stay orders against the ADR-based tax assessments for the tax year 2022. Although the ADR tax was rescinded through the Finance Act of 2023, it was reinstated for the tax year 2025, prompting renewed scrutiny of banks’ financial practices. The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is now under pressure to investigate these allegations thoroughly and enforce compliance to prevent further revenue losses.
Economic Implications: The alleged manipulation of ADRs by banks poses several risks:
- Revenue Loss: The government’s efforts to increase tax collection are undermined, exacerbating fiscal deficits.
- Market Distortion: Artificially inflated ADRs can mislead stakeholders about the actual lending activities and financial health of banks.
- Erosion of Trust: Such practices can diminish public confidence in the banking sector and financial regulatory bodies.
The unfolding scandal highlights the need for stringent regulatory oversight and transparent financial practices within Pakistan’s banking sector. Addressing these issues is crucial to ensuring the integrity of financial institutions and the effectiveness of fiscal policies aimed at economic development.
